Tuesday, January 18, 2011

Dartmouth Traditions: Horning

Some of the students expelled
in 1896, who called themselves
the "Backbone of '98"
Horning was a method used by students for expressing their grievance or discontent with a professor or even the College President. It was generally aimed at faculty who had handed down what the students felt were excessive assignments or unfair grades.

Though this tradition changed over time, at its height 100 to 200 masked students would surround the house of the unlucky professor in the middle of the night. They would then blow a variety of extremely noisy tin horns. Not content with simply disturbing the peace, they would sometimes tear down fences and throw rocks or other objects through the windows.

It is not known when the practice of horning began, though an entry in an early account book notes that Absolum Peters was charged 3 Shillings and 6 pence “To his part blowing the horn,” in 1776. The first mention of horning by name appears in the October, 1868 edition of The Dartmouth.  It is clear from this article that the practice had been going on for some time.

Ledger entry for Absolom Peters
Horning lasted until 1896 when President William Jewett Tucker expelled ten students for horning a professor in his office. The ten were reinstated when outraged alumni pointed it out that they were apprehended because they were honest enough to step forward and admit their involvement. As a condition of reinstatement, President Tucker also demanded that the student body agree to sign a statement ending the practice, which read in part: “Horning is a clumsy, ungentlemanly and unbecoming method of expressing grievance.”
The resolution against horning written by President Tucker and signed by representatives of the student body

Since then, students have found more appropriate and restrained means of dealing with complaints related to difficult assignments, capricious deadlines and complaints about grades.

To learn more, ask for:

Ledger B (DA-2 box 1746, p. 56 Absolom Peters)
Ruben Dearborn to Asa Dodge Smith, (Ms 868557.2)
The Dartmouth vol. 15 December 1, 1893, p 114
Resolution against Horning (Mss 896151)
Belknap, James, Class of 1898 Alumni File
Horn (Realia 10)
The “Horning” Episode,” The Dartmouth vol. 17 p. 303-5

2 comments :

  1. The vuvuzela of its day!

    I wonder, could Absalom's ledger entry be a credit, since 9 shillings minus 6 leaves 3? Students were paid to blow the conch shell to mark the beginning and end of classes in place of a bell.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Interesting point. I'd have to look at the entries a bit more carefully, but this a double entry accounting and the charge falls in the debit side, so I assume not this does not represent a credit.

    Peter Carini
    College Archivist

    ReplyDelete